Holiday Macaroni and Cheese
A small reprieve from all that richness—from buttermilk, my favorite not-so-secret ingredient, which gets added to the bechamel at the last minute.
Serves 4 as a main, 6 as a side
This macaroni and cheese is less “weeknight” and more “holiday,” meant to be served at a time when it seems not only reasonable but perhaps desirable to eat a dish full of pasta and dairy alongside a large-format meat and tons of wine. Not even because it’s especially labor intensive, more that it feels, well…special. It has a lot going for it: four unique and fabulous cheeses (you can skip one and go all-in on the cheddar or Gruyère, but the texture and flavor will be rewarded if you use both), a generous amount of black pepper, a whisper of nutmeg and a bit of thyme sprinkled over to finish. (I know you’ll be tempted, but don’t skip the nutmeg. Just commit right now to buying the whole jar knowing you’ll never use it all, but that it’ll be worth it for this dish alone.) Plus, there’s the unmistakable tang—a small reprieve from all that richness—from buttermilk, my favorite not-so-secret ingredient, which gets added to the bechamel at the last minute.
To achieve the proper finished texture for both the cheese sauce and the pasta, you might notice it feels especially saucy going into the oven—this is by design. After it bakes, you’ll be rewarded with properly cooked noodles, sauce thickened just so and an impossibly gorgeous brown crust, nary a breadcrumb in sight. This makes plenty for a smaller gathering, but can of course be doubled quite easily for larger parties or leftovers insurance. (Eating cold, leftover macaroni and cheese, all tight and congealed, is a secret pleasure of mine).
This is decadence, this is joy, this is a celebration. This is…your holiday macaroni and cheese.
Ingredients
- 4 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
- So much freshly ground black pepper
- A whisper of finely grated nutmeg
- 2 cups whole milk
- 4 ounces white cheddar, grated
- 4 ounces Gruyère cheese, grated
- 6 ounces fresh mozzarella cheese (from a ball), grated, divided
- 1 large garlic clove, finely grated
- ½ cup buttermilk (or more milk)
- Kosher salt
- 8 ounces cavatappi or elbow macaroni
- Parmesan cheese for grating on top, optional
- A few sprigs of thyme, optional
Preparation
- Preheat oven to 425°F. (If convection is an option, use it.)
- Melt butter in a medium pot over medium heat until starting to foam. Whisk in flour and cook, whisking constantly, until the roux is a pale shade of brown, 2–3 minutes. Add black pepper and nutmeg to toast the spices for 30 seconds or so.
- Slowly whisk in milk until smooth and no lumps remain. Add cheddar, Gruyère, about ¾ mozzarella and garlic, whisking to melt and blend.
- Add buttermilk (or more milk) and season well with salt and pepper. Remove from heat and set aside
- Cook pasta in a large pot of salted, boiling water until about halfway cooked (about half the time you usually boil your pasta—extremely al dente). Drain and shake off excess water as well as you can.
- Add pasta to the cheese mixture, stirring to coat very well, giving each noodle as much sauce exposure as it deserves. Transfer to a medium baking dish (an 8”x8” dish, 9” round cake pan or pie plate, an 8”–9” cast-iron pan, or anything approximately that size) and top with remaining mozzarella, Parmesan (if using), thyme (if using) and more black pepper (in that order).
- Transfer to the oven and bake until pasta is bubbling at the edges and gorgeously browned on top, 30–35 minutes (closer to 20–25 minutes for convection). Remove from the oven and let sit at least 5 or so minutes before serving.
Discussion